Jamie Stewart! I’m really glad to see that you’ve made full-blown songs, after years of just letting them be half-baked, or not even baked. Full arrangements, some of them even kinda catchy! Awesome, good job there. But I have a problem with your latest album, still; despite being musically engaging and tuneful, it still rings empty for me. In other words, you’ve successfully made me feel absolutely nothing concerning your songs.
This is a real shame, because your songs – instrumentally speaking – are doing all kinds of wonderous things. Care has been taken in the mixing of the elements. Take “Chocolate Makes You Happy” for instance; the segue between the distorted and noisy intro to the chorus could have been a trainwreck in the hands of a less experienced artist. Then there’s the danciness (perhaps an allusion to your current project, Former Ghosts?), complete with chugging 4/4 groovy bass, and the like. But the lyrics are anything but fun and worth dancing about; Stewart is lyrically slapping a girl in the face who is bulimic. Why address a song about a serious subject in this manner? Does it really have to be done like this? This is what I’m talking about, Stewart. You’ve successfully isolated me, and also in a way made me want to punch you in the face.
But at the same time, I can’t even get myself to want to punch you in the face. You see, your narcissistic self-pity party that you’ve had going on from the get go of your Xiu Xiu guise has just made me not give a damn in the end. It’s not even worth the time and trouble it’d take. Dear God, no wonder you hate yourself (assuming this is a true lyric, and you’re not jerking my chain with being an unreliable narrator).
Which isn’t to say that you don’t have some actual heart-felt moments on this album. “Hyunhye’s Theme” is a contender for your best song. Its subject is truly something – I hope that Hyunhye doesn’t die working herself away in that cubicle. Alas, the title track is right behind it and it kills any sympathy I was experiencing before. Thus, by the time this album is over, I feel nothing. NOTHING. Hope you have fun reliving synth pop.
No related content found.

Video: The Head And The Heart – “Down In The Valley”
February 9, 2012 at 1:56 PM
Watch: Bon Iver and The Roots – “Perth” (extended 8-minute jam on Fallon)
February 9, 2012 at 1:43 PM
Listen: Battles – “White Electric” (Shabazz Palaces remix)
February 9, 2012 at 1:18 PM
MP3s: Perfume Genius plays four new songs live in studio
February 9, 2012 at 1:16 PM
Kazu Makino spoke with Beats Per Minute to discuss the idea of songs as works in progress, the political climate in Japan, and what’s next in store for both Blonde Redhead and their new record label.
In light of their recent twentieth anniversary, Jaso Hirschhorn and Daniel Griffiths discuss Pearl Jam’s past, present and future.
Andrew Bailey runs through his personal top 5 R&B and Soul songs of all time. Agree? Disagree? Leave a comment.
© 2008-2012 One Thirty BPM LLC. All rights reserved. | About | Privacy | Terms of Use | Advertising | Staff | Contact | RSS Feed
Follow us on: Twitter | Facebook | Google+
Latest posts from The Film Stage
