Album Review: Cardi B – Am I The Drama?

[Atlantic; 2025]

Seven years is a long time to wait in pop, let alone in hip hop where careers can flare and fade in half that span. Yet Cardi B has always understood time differently. Since her Grammy-winning debut Invasion of Privacy in 2018, she has lived in the public eye as both a spectacle and a survivor: hit singles, viral moments, motherhood, relationship turmoil, courtroom appearances, endless scrutiny. All of it has only heightened the anticipation surrounding her sophomore record. Now, at last, Am I the Drama? arrives: a sprawling 23-track statement that asks not just whether Cardi is the center of attention, but whether she has become the very theater through which fame, gossip, and resilience play out.

The album wastes no time establishing its intent. “Hello” opens with the crackle of live news reports, the sound of journalists dissecting her every move, before Cardi interrupts with drill-infused bravado: “I’m that bitch”. It is both a reintroduction and a reminder, a curtain-raiser that frames the album as both performance and testimony. “Magnet” doubles down with club-ready aggression, a sweaty, high-octane workout jam that flexes Cardi’s voice as weapon and shield. Yet the record is not simply built on blunt force. “Pick It Up”, featuring Selena Gomez, slides into softer terrain: Selena’s smooth melodies wind around Cardi’s half-sung flow, stirring an intimate love song that trades hardness for tenderness. It’s an unexpected chemistry, and one of the album’s most surprising turns.

The range continues across the tracklist. “Bodega Baddie” folds in a Mexican harmonica against fast-paced percussion, balancing cultural wink with Cardi’s trademark bark. “Safe”, featuring Kehlani, is structured almost like a call-and-response between Kehlani’s rich vocal runs and Cardi’s sharp verses, a conversation in song that pivots between vulnerability and bravado. “Man Of Your Word” is among the album’s most powerful moments: an apologetic ballad of heartbreak and recovery, Cardi’s voice dipped in confession rather than confrontation. Then there is “What’s Goin’ On” with Lizzo, its piano chords and booming 808s providing a landscape for both inspiration and cockiness, Lizzo’s warmth softening Cardi’s sting.

Not every moment hits as cleanly. “Imaginary Playerz” feels caught between old-school hip hop homage and an uneven flow that struggles against its own beat. “Salute” and “Trophies” are serviceable trap anthems, big on swagger but light on surprise. Yet even the weaker cuts carry flashes of energy, with Cardi’s charisma ensuring the album never entirely slumps.

The guestlist here is both ambitious and strategic. Janet Jackson lends her presence to “Principal”, an anthem of confidence that feels like a generational passing of the torch. Tyla’s silky voice elevates “Nice Try” into sultry terrain, while Cash Cobain slinks through “Better Than You”, a sexually charged duet that twists beat patterns to accommodate his melodic rap against Cardi’s fire. Lourdiz appears on “On My Back,” a song of longing and desperation, offering a softer foil to Cardi’s armored delivery. And in a nod to continuity, the album closes with the seismic familiarity of “WAP” (with Megan Thee Stallion) and the 2021 single “Up”, both reminders of the hits that cemented Cardi’s superstardom.

At times, the sheer length of Am I the Drama? feels excessive. At 23 tracks and 71 minutes, it risks blurring into playlist territory rather than a tightly sequenced statement. But perhaps that is the point. Cardi’s public persona has never been singular: she is mother and mogul, victim and aggressor, spectacle and survivor. Multiplicity is her identity, and the album reflects it without apology.

Where the album succeeds most is in its emotional range. Tracks like “Flawwws” peel back the curtain to reveal insecurities about online addiction, overthinking, and the numbing churn of social media comparison. The song’s unsettled chord progression refuses resolution, embodying the endless scroll of doubt. Elsewhere, her confidence flares again, on “Killin You Hoes” on “ErrTime”, as if to remind us that vulnerability and bravado are not contradictions but companions in her world.

The timing of this release is crucial. In August and September 2025, Cardi has once again been engulfed in waves of rumor, legal headaches, and online dissection of her private life. Am I the Drama? feels like both an answer and a retort. It acknowledges the spectacle but insists on her authorship of it. The title isn’t just rhetorical, it’s reclamation. If she is the drama, then she owns the script.

What Cardi delivers here is not a flawless masterpiece, nor is it meant to be. Instead, it is messy, ambitious, sprawling, an album that mirrors the contradictions of its maker. It’s a record that moves from club to confession booth, from boast to breakdown, from spectacle to sincerity. In that chaos lies its truth. Cardi B has always thrived in the space between theater and honesty, and Am I the Drama? proves she can still turn her life, its noise, its pain, its resilience, into music that demands attention.

Seven years on, the crown is heavier, the scars more visible, the controversies louder. But Cardi’s voice, unfiltered and undeniable, is still hers. If she is the drama, then she is also the director, and this album is her stage.

66%